Who Would Say Such A Thing?

The smell hinted at the reality of the place they had just walked into. The faces told stories of pain, suffering and despair.


For those sitting in the shade of the balconies, the water before them represented hope. The sick, the blind, the cripple and the paralyzed. All of them here in the hope of being healed. It was said that the first person to get into the pool when the waters stirred would be healed of what ever it was that inflicted them. And so they waited. Watching. Hoping.

There was one particular man there, lying on a mat. Like everyone else at the pool, he too was waiting for his opportunity to be healed. But he had a problem. He had no one to help him. He had been this was for 38 years.

Suddenly, he noticed a stranger standing before him. “Would you like to get well?”, the stranger asked.

“Yes I would”, he replied. “But I can’t, because I have no one to help me! I’ve tried many times but someone always gets to the water before me.”

On hearing his reply, the stranger instructed the man, “Stand up! Pick up your mat and walk.”

The moment the words left his mouth, the man was healed. So he stood up, rolled up his mat and started walking. He had no idea who the man was and didn’t see which direction he went as he slipped back into the crowd. But what had happened to him hadn’t gone unnoticed.


Some religious leaders from the Temple saw the man carrying his sleeping mat, so they approached him and objected, “You can’t carry that mat. It’s the Sabbath and you are not allowed to do any work on the Sabbath!”

The man was stunned. “The man who healed me told me to pick up my mat and walk, so I did.”

“Who would say such a thing?” the religious leaders demanded to know.

But the man couldn’t tell them.

It wasn’t until later the same day that he would learn the identity of the stranger who had healed him. And soon the religious leaders would know too.

Take a moment to reflect on the story you have just read.
(sometimes it is helpful to read it again, slowly)

*Was there something in this story that you discovered—or thought about—for the first time?
*As you think about the story, what questions do you have? What do you wonder about?
*How might this story change your perspective / beliefs / behaviors?

I would love to hear what you are discovering as you think through these questions.
Comments are moderated to ensure they are relevant to the story and questions above.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: